Monday, November 1, 2010

La Vida De Los Muertos

In the Catholic Church, today is All Saints' Day, meant to commemorate those individuals who have already died and gone to heaven. Tomorrow on the Catholic calendar will be All Souls' Day, which recognizes those individuals who have died but who remain in purgatory, awaiting entrance into heaven. In Mexico, today and tomorrow also comprise El Día de los Muertos (The Day of the Dead), on which people remember and pray for loved ones who have died.

Today also marks two weeks since one of my dogs, Nellie Fox, a beagle-dachshund mix whom my wife and I rescued from the pound in 2002, passed away. Nellie took suddenly sick on the weekend of October 16-17. What seemed like a possible stomach ache or potentially passing illness on Sunday, October 17, escalated in the early morning of October 18. My wife and I rushed Nellie to a local emergency vet at 2:30 in the morning. This would turn into a trip for specialized care in Michigan about an hour and a quarter away. What was a furious and panicked drive north, when it seemed like Nellie could die at any moment, became hopeful, when she made it, the doctors stabilized her, and then they planned for surgery. When my wife and I left to head back home around 1:00 p.m., we knew the surgery might provide bad news in the form of cancer, but we also had hope. Nellie was awake, lucid, and stable when we left her. A little over an hour later, she was gone. During preparation for surgery, Nellie's heart gave out and the doctors were unable to resuscitate her.

I have felt pretty devastated by the loss of Nellie Fox, particularly since my wife and I had been getting her regular blood tests and checkups. Nellie's death has also extended a series of deaths that have hit my wife and I over the last few years. In May 2007, our chihuahua-terrier mix, Turbo, passed away after kidney failure. A year to the day later, my wife's mom died of a brain aneurysm. Then, this past May, my mom died of pancreatic cancer. Indeed, the very weekend that Nellie Fox became outwardly sick, I had gone to Indianapolis to commemorate my mom. A family friend, "Uncle" Dick McGowan, and his son, Cassidy, made an altar for my mom as part of the El Día de los Muertos display at the Indianapolis Art Center.

As I have been reflecting on these deaths over the last two weeks, I have found some comfort in the idea of El Día de los Muertos. The idea of celebrating, remembering, and engaging with the dead seems too overlooked in the culture that dominates United States society. Too often, people die, and the world seems to move on without pause, without consideration, without reflection, and sometimes even without sympathy. My wife commented on this when her mom died, I've felt it with the deaths of Turbo and my mom, and I'm feeling it as strongly as ever with the death of Nellie Fox. More time spent engaging with the dead, holding the things that they loved, focusing on vividly remembering the times we shared with them, and doing things that recall or honor them seems like a very spiritually useful and rewarding thing to do, not just for those of us still alive, but also for those who have died. Indeed, "un día" seems too little. "Una semana," "un mes," and even "un año" seem too little as well. So, I am proposing to spend and dedicate much more of my life for the dead--"mi vida para los muertos." I've already begun by making sure that I eat a banana--one of Nellie Fox's favorite foods--every day, thinking of Nellie when I do it.

On a related note, in a week and a half I will join millions of other people in going to the movie theater to watch the new Harry Potter film, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1, which depicts the first part of the seventh and final novel in the series. The morning of the day it opens, my "Reading Harry Potter" class, which I am teaching for the third time now this fall, will undoubtedly discuss it (though restrain ourselves somewhat for those who haven't seen it yet). I begin that course with an essay by C.S. Lewis called "Meditation in a Toolshed." In that essay, Lewis discusses the importance of both "looking at" and "looking along." He says we must both "look at" things, by examining them from outside of their perspectives, and "look along" things, by seeing the world from inside their perspectives. He argues that both are valuable for understanding the world. While we do a considerable amount of "looking at" in the Harry Potter course, I also consciously try to make sure that we "look along" Harry Potter, discussing what a perspective from inside the Potterverse offers the world. Among such things, the Harry Potter series, including to a large degree that seventh and final tale, offers us some ways to comprehend and come to terms with death--deaths of loved ones, deaths of people we do not know well, and deaths of ourselves. In the book Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Albus Dumbledore tells Harry that "the true master [of death] does not seek to run away from Death. He accepts that he must die, and understands that there are far, far worse things in the living world than dying" (720). This comes six years after Dumbledore, in the first book in the series (Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone) tells Harry that "to the well-organized mind, death is but the next great adventure" (297). It seems to me that looking along these ideas asks us to take stock of death more fully in life, not necessarily charging into death, but accepting death and seeking to find greater communion with our own mortality.

So much of the struggle with death comes from fears--fear of the unknown, fear of loss of one's self, fear of pain, and so on--and I have held these fears of death strongly throughout most of my life. But with my mom, my dogs, my mother-in-law, others I have known who have died, and the ideas presented by J. K. Rowling in mind, I seek a change in how I live life, embracing the dead more fully as part of my life, living with death instead of attempting to forget or deny its existence. I've only begun this new adventure, and I do not know where it will take me as I live it, but I also realize that I do not need or want to know, for that would not be in the spirit of living and walking with death. And realizing that does seem to organize my mind and my life quite a bit.

Friday, September 24, 2010

Apparently, Some Still Think Greed Is Good ...

Today, the Wall Street sequel hits theaters. Apparently, the "Greed is good" philosophy articulated by Gordon Gecko 25 years ago still has its ardent admirers. For a perfect case in point, see this opinion piece by Yaron Brook and Onkar Ghate on CNN.com.

On the one hand, I do have to give Brook and Ghate some credit. Many folks whom I see arguing for the advancement of the free market seem to act as if it is this wonderful, idyllic haven that allows for total freedom, which would include the freedom for individuals to develop their own moral codes. These proponents either fail to grasp or fail to mention that the free market system does set up a moral code--one of competition, adversarial relations, and the acquisition of profit, property, and capital. In a sense, these folks focus on the "free" part of "free market" without acknowledging the "market" part. At least Brook and Ghate publicly admit that the system contains and coerces people to follow a moral code.

On the other hand, Brook and Ghate are not as forthright as they could or really should be in discussing that moral code. Namely, they celebrate the industrialists of roughly 100 years ago for the progress that they produced, and they argue that big-money capitalists of the present day should be celebrated for making so much money, not for giving it away. In the end, they argue that "Science, freedom and the pursuit of personal profit -- if we can learn to embrace these three ideas as ideals, an unlimited future awaits." Unfortunately, they leave out that that future, while perhaps unlimited to some, is very limited to many. That time period of big-money capitalism that they celebrated also produced significant wealth gaps, exploitation of labor, and the foundations for the kinds of hegemonic control of middle and working classes that occurs today. Contemporary economic conditions and relations appear to reinforce quite readily many of those same kinds of things, with the kinds of anti-labor, unquestioning of business and capital attitudes to which so many of us have become socialized to subscribe; the continuing and increasing wealth gaps that occur both in the United States and around the world; and the many ways that business organizations hold control over people's everyday lives, both at work and in their leisure time. That emphasis on pursuit of personal profit--i.e., the idea that a society of individuals motivated by self-interest--not only reinforces, but expands the inequities already built into the system. Those who have power, capital, and authority have much fuller, greater, and more extensive opportunities to increase those things than those who don't. Thus, we get incredible wealth gaps. We also see, in the process, how oppressions on the basis of race, gender, religion, ability, and other forms of social identities are perpetuated and advanced by the very economic system that purports to espouse opportunity, as those with capital and power can use that to gain more capital and power, while those with less (e.g., women, non-white folks, non-Christian folks, non-wealthy folks, etc.) do not have such opportunities.

Meanwhile, Brook and Ghate leave out a really significant part of the equation--luck. Folks like ex-baseball executive Branch Rickey have been fond of saying, "Luck is the residue of design." There probably is some truth to that in that the more well-designed a plan is, the more contingencies it takes into account, and thus the more it can prevail through adverse situations or be in position to take advantage of serendipitous developments. On the other hand, as humans who are very limited in our capacities to see and know, we must depend on luck regardless of our designs. A poorly timed natural disaster, the development of a sudden debilitating health condition, unforeseeable incompetent or malicious actions by others, or any number of other situations can bring down even well-laid plans. Additionally, there is the element of being able to have the knowledge and foresight to design well in the first place. This involves the concept of cultural capital, as theorized by Pierre Bourdieu, which is cultural knowledge that a person who has can use to gain opportunities within a cultural system. I can work really hard and plan (i.e., design) really meticulously, but if I don't have the cultural capital to know how to take advantage of the system, it likely won't do me a lot of good. As so many of us are not raised in situations in which we can gain that knowledge as we grow up and then are so busy trying to make ends meet as adults that we don't have the requisite time to learn it once we have grown (or we're not allowed access to it based on some discriminating factors within the system), we end up unable to set up good designs and, thus, see pursuit of personal profit come to fruition--or at least as full of fruition as those who have already been given advantages.

In the end, as Brook and Ghate indicate, capitalism does invoke a moral code. It does not ultimately, though, seem to be one that's particularly consistent with a fuller, more working democracy. And, regardless of what they claim, the only "unlimited future" that I see awaiting in the system Brook and Ghate espouse is one for the advantaged, lucky few.

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Douche and Turd

Recently, fed up with my choices among Democrats and Republicans, I became associated with Dan La Botz's campaign for the Senate from the state of Ohio. La Botz is running as the Socialist party candidate for the Senate seat. As part of that involvement, I was introduced to and I signed the Petition for Inclusive Senate Candidate Debates in Ohio. This evening, I and others who signed the petition received an email message from Bruce Winges of the Akron Beacon Journal. This was the text of his message:

The Ohio News Organization generally follows the structure used by the Commission on Presidential Debates, which allows for only the major-party candidates to debate. The logic is sound: In a television debate format, when time constraints limit the number of questions and answers to be heard, it is of the utmost importance that voters hear from the two candidates who are clearly the front-runners for the office. While we have and will continue write about third-party candidates when warranted, including them in debates limits Ohioans' ability to hear answers from the top candidates on issues critical to the state's future.

I wrote back tonight, nearly immediately after receiving Mr. Winges' message. This was the text of my response:

Dear Mr. Winges,

Thank you for your response to the Petition for Inclusive Senate Candidate Debates in Ohio. While I understand the logical argument that you have articulated, and it is, as you claim, "sound" from a particular perspective, it is not universally sound. Indeed, this is the logic of privilege and oppression--a logic that many, myself included, would not characterize as "sound." By this logic, those who have great advantages in society are given the opportunity to further those advantages for the simple reason that they have the advantages in the first place. In the process, to quote an old line, "the rich get richer and the poor get poorer." Given, to echo your word, how critical this debate is, at a moment when the state, the country, and the world are witnessing a very significant set of crises that includes deep economic recession, environmental destruction, and escalation of significant and at times violent political animosities, among other things, there would seem to be no better time than now to include alternative voices to the two major parties--the very parties who have played significant roles in orchestrating the set of critical circumstances that we now face. If the Tea Party movement has shown us nothing else, it should illustrate that people on all sides of the political spectrum are not happy with the status quo of the two-party oligarchy. By not allowing alternative voices, particularly out of an argument based on the front-runner status of the Democratic and Republican candidates, you effectively help keep a pair of already aristocratically-endowed organizations in power. The debate becomes the latest in the long line of practices that hand over the reigns (pun entirely intended) to these parties through a process known as kingmaking whereby the political elites along with the heavy cooperation of media institutions, as well as cooperation of other institutions, have extremely high influence over the choices, proposals, and ideas available during an election--often to the point of determining these very things.

Additionally, this kind of practice constitutes exactly the kind of critique that candidates like Dan La Botz bring to table--namely, that the system of capitalism, with its emphasis on profit-making and the acquisition of capital, plays a significant role in reproducing power and equity differences, in diminishing the possibilities for a fuller and more effectively working democracy in which as many voices as possible can be heard, and in perpetuating the kinds of circular logical claims from within the system that keep people from getting real opportunities to see, express, or disseminate critiques that dmonstrate the problems incurred by the sytem of capitalism itself. This is what is called false consciousness and what is called hegemony in a nearly perfect nutshell, perpetuating the curtain over the eyes of the electorate, using appeals to justify unearned power differences so that the electorate--especially those of less privilege--accept these power differences, and keeping the country from finding a fuller democracy.

While I understand the argument that this is just following industry practice, I do not accept that argument. Indeed, as part of classes on culture and communication that I teach, students and I examine exactly how industry practices in all kinds of fields--especially, when we examine popular culture, within media industries--perpetuate status quo relations that perpetuate oppression. Relying on an argument of standard industry practice utilizes the kind of circular logic of oppression that is emblematic of capitalism--the kinds of circular logic to which I alluded above. Frankly, I am disappointed in your use of such a transparently flawed argument, and I urge you and your colleagues on the Ohio News Organization to reconsider your decision.

Sincerely,

Raymond I. Schuck
Bowling Green, Ohio


When I teach the class on political communication at Bowling Green State University, which I am doing this semester, during the first week we watch the episode of South Park from 2004 titled "Douche and Turd." In many ways, issues raised within the episode seem to relate quite readily to the above exchange. As I hope my response to Mr. Winges above conveys, I think there's more to it than what the episode of South Park suggests; however, I think the episode provides a useful starting point for discussion of concerns with the contemporary two-party system of politics in the United States. Those are exactly some of the concerns that these Ohio Senate debates will fail to address by only including the Republican and Democratic candidates.

Thursday, September 2, 2010

More Big Brother Thoughts

Last week, I posted some thoughts on the current season of Big Brother. Two days later, on the telecast on Thursday, August 26, the same kind of issue that I had addressed came up again. In this instance, when Matt was evicted from the house, during his post-eviction interview with host Julie Chen, he referred to fellow houseguest Britney as a "succubus." Instantly, Chen told Matt to "keep it clean." Matt responded by saying that the FCC allows the word, to which Chen suggested that that didn't mean it should be said on this telecast.

On the one hand, this draws attention to the inappropriateness of using some terms. So, in a way it addresses my point from my previous post. On the other hand, it does so in a way that doesn't really address the issue. Rather than simply stating that using the word is inappropriate under the same kind of "family programming" veneer that's been used on previous episodes, Chen could have allowed Matt his use of the word and then challenged his use of it, pointing out how it is derogatory toward women and how it reinforces the system of sexism in United States society.

With that in mind, I see this as a missed opportunity that ends up reinforcing the same kinds of things I brought up last week. As I mentioned, I'm very much for the liberalization of language use. To do otherwise keeps people from actually discussing and dealing with problems. In this case, Matt's use of a derogatory word is called out as inappropriate without explanation of why it might be inappropriate. All this reflects and teaches is a dictatorial kind of rule--i.e., "Don't do this because I said so." In the end, that doesn't address the systematic oppression of women that this term, along with other terms that continue to be allowed like "bitch" and "ho," reflects. In fact, given how much patriarchy has historically given the same kind of "just because" reasoning when women have attempted to challenge gendered oppression, it can be argued that this kind of treatment of use of "succubus" reinforces oppressions of many kinds (including gender) by reinforcing the idea that those with less power should not do or say things simply because those in power tell them not to, regardless of the legitimacy or illegitimacy of the reasons that those in power have for what they have commanded others to do or not to do. That, to me, seems like a very dangerous lesson--a lesson of brushing problems under the rug rather than dealing with them that leads society little of anywhere but continued hegemony, as the powerful maintain and grow their power because attention has been deferred from looking at the ways that power works, particularly as it works in oppressive manners.

I don't necessarily blame Chen here. She's asked by CBS and the producers of the show to fulfill a role within certain social and industry expectations. She's in a position where she could address the bigger issue of oppression, so it's disappointing that she doesn't. She's also, though, in a role where she could easily be dismissed should she articulate things that CBS or the show's producers don't like. Media companies, media industries, and the folks that own and run these institutions have a much higher degree of culpability. Of course, CBS is also subject to a bigger game of hide and don't seek, which is particularly acute for them since they were the network that received heavy fines by the FCC after the "wardrobe malfunction" in the Justin Timberlake/Janet Jackson performance during the 2004 Super Bowl. So, it is political and economic systems and institutions that are creating this kind of situation. And that just seems to suggest all the more fully that we need greater and fuller analysis and critique of the system of capitalism that sets many of the rules for life in the contemporary U.S. world. Of course, with these same institutions and systems developing even greater and greater influence over schools, media, and other educational experiences on all levels, that critique becomes even tougher to express and sustain.

And, as this occurs, to quote F. Scott Fitzgerald writing 85 years ago, "so we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past." Perhaps, though, I should be quoting George Orwell's 1984. After all, the show does take its name from that book, and the social critiques offered by that book seem to apply so readily to the whole situation.

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Big Brother is Watching Out for the Whole Family

I don't normally watch the television show Big Brother. Other than a few moments here and there in which I've happened across it and a couple times in the last two years when I put Big Brother After Dark on with no sound for something on television while I was working, I have never paid attention to the show, and I've certainly never become invested in the show in any way before. However, I am watching Big Brother this season because I know one of the contestants. Ragan Fox, with whom (as I've mentioned on this blog before) I went to graduate school, is on the show this summer. So, I'm watching.

There are plenty of things to comment about in connection with the show. The kinds of things that the competitions emphasize, the relationships between the houseguests and CBS as a network, and the ways that the producers edit and present the footage to produce the show are all ripe for examination. Among all of this, one particular situation has caught my attention.

A few weeks ago, when host Julie Chen asked Ragan what it was like to be taped to a wall in one of the competitions, Ragan responded by joking that that's just a typical Friday night for him. Immediately, Chen moved on, citing that this is "family" programming. In another episode, when another of the contestants--Rachel--cursed when frustrated during a competititon (and had this censored out by the network), Chen told her to "keep it clean." Clearly, then, the producers of the show hope to present this as "clean," "family" entertainment during the 8:00 primetime block, and they see joking about one's night life (I'm assuming especially for an openly gay man to be the one doing the joking) and using certain kinds of language as inconsistent with that image.

Given that, it's telling what does seem okay for "good, clean" programming. Notably, numerous guests have referred to women repeatedly and consistently as "bitches," while a group of guys who call themselves "The Brigade" have used the phrase "bros, not ho's" to declare their loyalty to their all-male alliance. Apparently, then, derogatory references to women--and the misogyny that comes with it--have become "clean," "family" programming on CBS. To me at least, that sounds a lot more damaging than vague allusions to sexual exploits on a Friday night and words like "fuck" and "shit," which don't directly attack people as these other terms do.

Now, we might argue that in fact the show is countering misogyny by depicting the users of the terms "bitch" and "ho" in unflattering lights, perhaps using this to convey the idea that using these terms is damaging and/or inappropriate. However, one look at message boards in places like this seems to suggest that that's not the kind of message a lot of people get from the show. Rather, there appears to be a lot of buying into use of these terms as okay.

I tend to be all for the liberalization of language use. I think we could use a lot more openness in terms of what can be publicly discussed and how it can be publicly discussed. I've argued things along those lines on this blog before. The allowance of terms like "bitch" and "ho" on network television has become part of that liberalization process. Twenty or thirty years ago, we wouldn't have heard these things on primetime network television programming. Yet, we need to be cognizant of the way that this process proceeds. Namely, it's telling what choices media programs and organizations make about what is now considered "okay" and what remains considered "inappropriate," particularly given how much footage from the Big Brother house is left out in the editing and arranging processes for the actual episodes that air. And it's telling what ideologies--in this case ideologies regarding gender--these choices promote and reflect. In this case, Big Brother sure seems to be suggesting that mistreatment of women, loyalty among men against villianized women, and verbal abuse of women are meaningful and acceptable aspects of regular and appropriate family life. The producers of the show choose what they want to portray to viewers, and these choices seem pretty misguided.

Sunday, August 1, 2010

More Stupid Baseball Nicknames

A couple of years ago, I blogged about the ridiculousness of the trend of baseball nicknames following on the heels of A-Rod in which people combine part of the player's first name and part of the player's last name. I also suggested where this might lead, with Albert Pujols becoming "A-jols" and Pat Neshek becoming "P-Nes."

Well, I saw another one last night, calling Rockies' outfielder Carlos Gonzalez "CarGo." Obviously, there are a few different puns that can work with this name, but the same can be said for "V-Mart" for Victor Martinez and "Man-Ram" for Manny Ramirez. In the end, they all seem inspid. Yet, they seem to prevail.

And if that's the case, then I'm still hoping that Kevin Youkilis has a relative named Frank or Fred or something who makes it to the major leagues and provides one of these nicknames that actually has some appeal.

Monday, July 19, 2010

To the Left, to the Left ...

How about if we start out with a bit of Beyoncé ...

A few years ago I came up with the following philosophy about contemporary U.S. politics: Most Republicans are jackasses, most Democrats are dumbasses, and most third-party and independent candidates try to be smartasses. And when you've got a bunch of asses, what they produce is a bunch of crap.

It was an attempt to be pithy, though more recently I'm thinking it may be too crass and generalized. It certainly suggests some things about my own ideological assumptions. That said, I still think there is something to the basic sentiments it's trying to suggest, and I think a recent situation involving Sarah Palin is a good example of this.

Apparently, Palin made a series of attempts on Twitter to comment on the proposal to build a mosque near the World Trade Center site in Manhattan. In the process, she said "refudiate," which is not actually a word. Some on the left have picked this up as a reason to make fun of her, suggesting or implying once again that this is further evidence that she is quite intellectually challenged.

Now, I am far from a fan of Palin. I think she has been embarrassing in her lack of eluctionary abilities, her apparent lack of even fundamental knowledge of things about which she speaks, and her continued use of simple rhetorical constructions that lack merit, consistency, and coherence. So, I can understand frustration that she has become a prominent political figure in this country. On the other hand, I think focusing energy on her use of "refudiate" is silly, petty, and actually damaging.

I make speaking mistakes all the time. Few, if any, people don't. In fact, during the 2008 election, when folks pointed out the many articulation flaws of Palin, many individuals on the right and in the media would then suggest how Joe Biden isn't perfect either, with reference to gaffes he made. This always frustrated me because making speaking blunders here and there differs significantly from consistently being unable to articulate much of anything with coherence. The former is entirely forgiveable as part of being human; the latter is typically a sign of incompetence. Joe Biden, I believe, fit the former; Sarah Palin, on the other hand, has consistently seemed to fit the latter. Perhaps she will improve. She may gain understanding of issues, learn the nuances of positions, and develop her elocutionary skills. Indeed, an appearance with William Shatner on The Tonight Show a while back actually impressed me. In the meantime, I believe that many of her recent statements and comments show that she still has a long way to go.

And this, I think, gets me back to the political philosophy with which I began. That philosophy called Republicans "jackasses" because so many of them seem so willing to use anything to gain and maintain power. They're effective at it, and they can be downright ruthless about it, not seeming to care about the consequences or consistency of the rhetoric they espouse. As conservatives, they also have power already on their side. The rhetorical concept of burden of proof suggests that in a debate the burden of proof lies with the party trying to challenge what is already assumed. Those arguing from what is already assumed enjoy the privilege of resting on that assumption until it is challenged enough to be questioned or overturned. Conservatism, by definition, has this power of assumption, and conservatives today quite readily use it, even when the things they say are ultimately inconsistent and incoherent.

Meanwhile, when Democrats get power or get good opportunities to use power, they screw it up over and over again. While freely admitting that this is tied to my own ideological leanings, I tend to think that the left has better ideas. No one's ideas are perfect, but when weighed rationally and with nuance, I think generally the left's arguments tend to have more depth. Indeed, that's actually something Republicans play up, though in a different way, with anti-intellectual rhetoric about leftist elites. In other words, pointing out logical inconsistencies and articulating nuanced positions become devalued, as if doing these things constitutes a problematic view of the world and a means of oppressing other people. Notice, though, that I say "the left," not "Democrats" when I mention these ideas. Two reasons account for this. One is that I think that for the most part the Democratic party in this country isn't really on the left politically. The second is that many of the Democrats I hear don't really go about making arguments for good ideas or don't go about doing it effectively, so I can't group them here. In other words, they're dumbasses.

Making fun of Sarah Palin seems like another instance in which Democrats and others reinforce that assessment. And, ultimately, I think it plays right into the hands of the likes of Sarah Palin and her supporters. Picking on instances like this provides fuel for Palin to continue to identify herself as a victim of the left and of the "lamestream" media, as she likes to call it. (And, by the way, I would argue that the media does have a liberal bias, as so many claim, but I would add the caveat that it's a liberal bias within what is already a conservative frame, which makes it essentially a moderately conservative bias.) Palin does have a long pattern of consistent inability to articulate herself that suggests a lack of competence. Maybe in some way using the word "refudiate" reflects that, but it's such an easy, everyday kind of blunder to make that I don't think it's a big deal, and I don't think a big deal should be made of it. There are plenty of much more potent examples to use to show Palin's apparent lack of competence that the argument does not need examples like this to make that case. To do so seems like it aids the narrative that she (along with her political advisors) has constructed for herself, and it allows her and her supporters to shift attention from the actual content of her statement, which I think is very problematic and the much more important issue here, to her image as victim of the media and the left.

Palin may be incompetent when it comes to solutions and complex explanations of contemporary social, political, and economic issues. She may be becoming more competent as she is learning more about those issues. She appears to be relatively competent at promotion and public relations, recognizing an audience to which she appeals and finding a way to keep appealing to it. Certainly, both of these types of competence play roles in contemporary U.S. politics. I think, though, engaging more with the ideas she promotes as much as possible would be the much more effective and much more humane path for the left. Perhaps, though, that's the problem with the contemporary left. In Ancient Rome, Cicero called rhetoric the combination of eloquence and wisdom. Perhaps the left needs to learn how to focus more fully on consistently stating any wisdom it has in more eloquent terms to make their statements more impenetrable from the anti-intellectual attacks of the right. Petty squabbling over use of the pseudo-word "refudiate" seems anything but this. Indeed, it makes one look like many Democrats look of late (i.e., like a "dumbass") or look like an elitist who engages in attacks on other people's lack of cultural capital as a means of humoring herself/himself (i.e., like a smartass). And whether it's Palin levelling it against Muslims or her detractors levelling it against her, I'm tired of all of the crap.